Skip to main content

Should Teachers Be Warm and Fuzzy?

I received my Spring 2010 evaluations yesterday. They were the best I've ever had, which was great. But in the midst of the positive comments, multiple students complained that I was cold and unapproachable, and uninterested in hearing their problems.

This all true. I'm not a warm and fuzzy teacher, and I'm not flexible about the standards for the class. Despite what they think, I do wish the best for my students. But I am very aware of my role is in their lives: I'm their sociology professor. I'm not their father, their counselor, their friend, or their confidant. I think I'm really good at teaching them sociology and I know I'd be pretty cruddy at doing those other things.

My instinct is to ignore the comments and focus on the positive, as well as the critical feedback that strikes me as more constructive. But I'm curious why students feel compelled to critique me for my warmth, and lack thereof.

Comments

  1. Interesting criticism, and I'm not sure I'd throw it out, but I suspect there's a difference between personal "warmth" and an ability to listen in such a way that people feel heard, regardless of whether or not you solve their problems for them. I've interacted with people who weren't particularly cuddly but did strike me as interested in what I had to say and respectful of me as a person. I've also known "warm" people who didn't seem particularly sincere. There's something else here. Your job, as I see it, is to suss out whether the students are asking you to be a cookie-baking sweetheart, or if what they're really telling you is that they don't feel particularly heard and respected. Tossing out critique that doesn't fit your current understanding of your approach to teaching would, essentially, invalidate the thoughts and feelings of the students who offered it.

    Have you read any of Marshall Rosenberg's work on Nonviolent Communication? It's probably worth perusing if you haven't. While I find his tone a little annoying at times, the observations/feelings/needs/request model is effective even when you are ultimately not going to bend your standards.

    For what it's worth, parenting and teaching can overlap significantly. Perhaps investigating your assumptions about the differences between the two could help to get to the source of the students' critique?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Returning to add that I understand that you have purposefully chosen not to entangle yourself in the emotional lives of your students. This strikes me as a very appropriate and professional choice. It is possible to acknowledge the feelings of students and thereby provide validation to them without emotional involvement. That is, acknowledging that feelings exist is not the same as engaging in an emotionally charged relationship with the student.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Credit Reports and FICO Scores

I'm in the process of tidying up my finances. Suze Orman's The Money Book for the Young, Fabulous and Broke has been a fantastic resource because it gives clear, straightforward advice in language I can understand. Orman's first rule, and she is very insistent on this, is that you have to know your FICO score, also known as your credit rating. You probably know that this score is used to determine your eligibility for mortgages and car loans. According to the New York Times it is also often used by employers to decide if you are a good job candidate. So even if you're not shopping for a loan, it is a good idea to know your score. BUT, before you check your score, you should check the information your score is based on--your credit reports. You actually need to look at 3 credit reports, one from each of the major agencies (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion). But you only need to go to one website to get started. AnnualCreditReport.com allows you to obtain one fr...

The Jack Wolgin International Competition

I recently joined the advisory committee for Temple's new major art prize, the Jack Wolgin International Competition . This prize awards $150,000 to an international artist, chosen from a pool of select nominees. Three finalists are invited to share their work in an exhibition that runs throughout October. Panels and other events dot the calendar across the month. Near the end of the exhibit, all 3 artists come in for a 3 day artists-in-residency. At the end of the residency, a winner is announced. The winner gives a public lecture the following day. My role on the committee is to direct an impact assessment, examining the prize's effects on Temple University, the Philadelphia art world, and the artists themselves. This is tricky work, and I'll share some of our research design here, in hopes of getting some feedback and fresh ideas. Measuring Impacts on the University: Our first and easiest measurement here is to track media hits that are generated because of the a...

What's in Your Writer's Backpack

George Clooney's character in Up in the Air is a motivational speaker who begins his talks by setting a backpack on a table next to his podium, opening it, and then leaning in to the microphone to ask "What's in your backpack?" The character wants his audience to feel the weight of all that ties them down. I'm going to use the same question in a writing workshop tomorrow for faculty and graduate students. But I'm using the question very differently. I want my participants to take stock of all of the writing resources they already have, many of which they take for granted. The workshop actually brings together two different writing retreats: one for graduate students writing dissertations and one for faculty working on books or articles. Having been in both camps, I'll start with iconic stories from each experience: The horror of the blank page: When I was a graduate student, I followed my dissertation proposal defense with a heavy summer teaching load...